Сообщений в теме: 2905

[sanchouz]

klas, uzhe vtoroy god podryad nashi stanovyatsia chempionami, nadeyus v sledushem sezone kto to iz nih smozhet voiti v pervuyu komadu

[Ray]

Нуу в следующем им ещё рано, но в перспективе - да, пару-тройку из них смогут претендовать на место во взрослой команде.
Посмотрим как у прошлого, тоже чемпионсокго, поколения дела пойдут - пока вроде всё идёт хорошо, прогрессируют, тьфу-тьфу-тьфу.

[PETER_ARSENAL]

Есть обзорчик матча, а то пропустил вчера?

[Home Alone]

Я постараюсь, когда приеду домой обзор закинуть.

[SVD]

Наши "уважаемые пассажиры" видимо уступают 1-е места женщинам и детям.

[mArt_]

Arsenal 5-3 Nottm Forest
FA Premier Academy League, Emirates Stadium
Tuesday, May 11, 2010, 14:00

1 тайм
//www.megaupload.com/?d=6BRGE0IU

2 тайм
//www.megaupload.com/?d=7KGR9NVA

Сообщение отредактировал mArt_: 12 May 2010 - 15:11

[Twin Peaks]

вот Афобе вообще жду не дождусь к основе поближе

[Home Alone]

Эдик, к сожалению, видимо боссы Арса не считают Эвину = Клиши. Они до сих пор ему не предложили продлить контракт, и он уже задумывается над уходом.
Хотя я жду...

[Home Alone]

Нереально лень писать блог, так что пока просто выставлю фотки ЧЕМПИОНОВ!!! =)) (кое-что с официалки, кое-что Даниэль прислал)
а обзор уже выше написан...
//s42.radikal.ru/i097/1005/6d/81d717a494b7.jpg
//s004.radikal.ru/i205/1005/31/5b252c555d78.jpg
//s49.radikal.ru/i123/1005/46/9c3976b76760.jpg
//s003.radikal.ru/i201/1005/75/f75080630a7f.jpg
//s54.radikal.ru/i143/1005/27/ef134471f974.jpg
//s54.radikal.ru/i145/1005/67/f19a5df15805.jpg
//s39.radikal.ru/i084/1005/94/66af39a7af6a.jpg
//s08.radikal.ru/i181/1005/29/db465551db37.jpg
//s48.radikal.ru/i119/1005/1e/31dc4bc25940.jpg
//i073.radikal.ru/1005/36/50d714ce0b34.jpg
//s006.radikal.ru/i213/1005/0d/2883484ea62e.jpg
//s52.radikal.ru/i136/1005/1c/4ab7f3ce151a.jpg
//s06.radikal.ru/i179/1005/ce/a8b372466250.jpg
//s005.radikal.ru/i209/1005/16/88d08714b23f.jpg
//s001.radikal.ru/i193/1005/dd/6e6cfbddd692.jpg
//s13.radikal.ru/i186/1005/df/c34fb34ff6ff.jpg
//s50.radikal.ru/i130/1005/b6/d93173c2f928.jpg

[Home Alone]

Один молодой человек, Рики, кинул инфу для размышления. Он побывал на фан сайтах клубов, в которых играли наши арендованные ребята, и задал несколько вопросов:
1. Как провел этот игрок свою аренду в вашем клубе?
2. На какой позиции играл данный футболист?
3. Его сильные и слабые стороны
4. Взяли бы вы его еще раз в аренду?
5. Достаточно ли он хорош, чтобы заиграть в первой команде Арсенала в следующем сезоне, или хотя бы в недалеком будущем?

Ответы на английском языке.

Скрытый текст

Jay Simpson
Queens Park Rangers (Coca-Cola Championship)
Apps: 38+3 Goals: 13
Loan started: August 27
Loan end: End of season

Northernr wrote:
How has Jay played for you this season?
Much like the rest of the team started well and faded. Looked on course for a good haul of goals but hit the buffers in the last three months, performances dropped and missed chances became the order of the day.
What sort of position/role has he played?
Up front, by himself, with next to no support or service. This has been the case with strikers at QPR ever since furlong left.
What are his strengths and weaknesses?
He holds the ball up and lays it pretty well and for the first two thirds of the season at least his finishing was spot on although that' gone to cock lately. He's not very good in the air, or particularly mean and ruthless, and he's certainly not good enough for the prem.
Would you take him back on loan next season?
No, either buy him or look elsewhere.
Is he good enough to play for the Arsenal first team next season, or will he be in the future?
No and no

Tonto Cole wrote:
How has Jay played for you this season?
started off wioth a bang, but got an injury early in 2010 and his form/confidence tailed off. 12 goals in a season is not a bad return however.
What sort of role has he played?
Strangely in a single striker role, which isnt ideal. When we hit our golden patch in October, it worled well asd he had the support of 2 or 3 attacking midfielders, when we wnet through the bad patch in January/Feb he was isolated and the role didnt suit him.
What are his strengths and weaknesses?
For a small bloke he holds the ball up reasonably well, but in the presnce of a physical defender he couldnt cope. he is pacy, which helps and is a willing worker, which goes down well int hese parts.
Would you take him back on loan next season?
I would, and would even buy him, but others on here disagree. If he had a taller, phsyical striker along side him, then he would do better IMO. At the end of the day it depends on which system we want to use.
Is he good enough to play for the Arsenal first team next season, or will he be in the future?
To be honest - no. So if you would kindly sell him to us for £1.50, we could take his wages off you allowing you to buy some french youngster instead.

CanadaRanger wrote:
A view from a distance...
Simpson is presently a decent Championship level player. His development (and goals scored) will not reach potential without a strike partner with whom he has had time to develop good positional and strategic understanding (someone about whom Simpson can say "I know where he is and I know what he is likely going to do and wants me to do").
I suggest Arsenal wait to see if QPR brings in a strike partner, and if so, who... If they do not, then take him back so that he can reach his full potential for YOU elsewhere. If they do, then loans are not they way QPR wants to go forward. Sell him to QPR and see how he develops in better surroundings than he has had.
You can always put a "right of first refusal" clause into the sale contract... Useful (to you) if he does great at QPR in the next couple of seasons under the new Management. Warnock WILL get the best out of all of the players.

gazza1 wrote:
Sorry to go against the grain with my fellow 'punters' on this MB but........
Simpson has been pretty average for most of the season. If he was any good he would have shone through because we have been very limited up front. In the end I preferred to see Priskin playing ahead of him & sometimes a 18 year old who struggles to control the ball & is very average as well.
Scored 12 goals but missed more than double that amount, 1 on 1's against the keeper is a poor, holding the ball up is less than average, hence why when it gets knocked up to him it comes pretty well straight back, cant head the ball....works pretty hard though. We only had 2 or 3 strikers at the club and Simpson was left out frequently in the end because he was so poor.(mind you I am told he was injured.....hmmm)
He will never play for Arsenal in the Premier, would struggle playing above Div 1 and may find that too difficult as well.

Wojciech Szczesny
Brentford (League One)
Apps: 27
Loan started: November 20
Loan end: End of season

clad1 wrote:
IMO, Strengths - goal keeping. Weaknesses - Kicking, youth.
Makes occasional mistakes but learns from them.
Would we have him back?. Silly question. Absolutely YeS.
Next season he would probably not be good enough to keep 1st place at Arsenal, but with the right experience and loan club(e,g. Brentford League 1 next season and Brentford Championship following season)then he would be good enough.

Hanwell_Bee wrote:
1) Played brilliantly this season
2) Strengths: shot stopping and reaction saves Weaknesses: Can over react (see penalty decisions v Huddersfield and Carlisle) or is that just passion for the game?
3) definately
4) If Fabianski is considered good enough, then hand Chesney the number 1 shirt now!

Paul O'Brien wrote:
He's been outstanding in every department. Bar a couple of goals he let in when he misjudged high balls (both in the same game) and one or two penalties, I can't say he's let in any goals that were his fault. Shot-stopping brilliant (from the stable of Nigel Martyn); one-on-ones outstanding (think Neville Southall or Peter Schmeichel); decision-making sure and confident; crosses very good; kicking I think is good (often likes to kick low and long to a specific player).
Downsides: as has already been mentioned: like his fellow Pole Boruc, he's passionate (perhaps too much so) and seems occasionally to be confident to the point of arrogance which may or may not work in his favour. I'm not yet certain of his ability to organise his defence other than at freekicks, nor does he seem to shout at the defence when he lets one in as much as some goalise like van der Saar. These may be down to youth or (as I've never spoken to him) language differences.
He also doesn't score enough goals, which is disappointing iven his other attributes.
I'd have him back tomorrow.
He's certainly good enough right now for a runout in a few preseason games to test him out, and for League Cup/FA Cup matches. I think once he's been played in these, M. Wenger will realise he has an absolute gem on his hands. He could be around as long as Seaman - if someone else doesn't grab him first.
But of course all this depends on him having another 10 seasons at the Bees to finish learning his trade

Henri Lansbury
Watford (Coca-Cola Championship)
Apps: 34+4 Goals: 4
Loan started: August 21
Loan end: End of season

watfordfc88 wrote:
How has Henri played for you this season? - not really a big fan to be honest, did well in some games, didnt in others. likes to be involved in the play
What sort of position/role has he played? - he has played just behind the front players, also dropped back into central midfeild, where he seems to be more comfortable.
What are his strengths and weaknesses? good pace, positioning. passing lets him down.
Would you take him back on loan next season?
probaly not, he'l stay in Arsenal reserves for another year
Is he good enough to play for the Arsenal first team next season, or will he be in the future? i dont think he's good enough to play for arsenal. but Mr Wenger must see something in him.

lambo21 wrote:
How has Henri played for you this season? Looked very good in the two games we were on sky, apart from them two hes been good but was outdone by Cleverley.
What sort of position/role has he played? started off playing behind the striker in a 4-5-1 where i think he looked better when helguson cam back he was shiffted back in centre mid in a 4-4-2 where he showed glimpses.
What are his strengths and weaknesses? Good player likes to get forward, always wants the ball and looks like a born winner. weaknesses are he goes mssing sometimes and sometimes decision making at time isnt the best.
Would you take him back on loan next season? any day of the week
Is he good enough to play for the Arsenal first team next season, or will he be in the future? Next year no but in the future he could be good for maybe a top 10 prem team maybe not arsenal but for a forward thinking player he likes a tackle so someone arsenal may need.

SvenskaBålgeting wrote:
How has Henri played for you this season? Got better as the season went on, finished a crucial part of our midfield.
What sort of position/role has he played? Box to box
What are his strengths and weaknesses? Drives forward very well and has a good engine, his range of passing and vision is good too. Isn't scared to get stuck in either. HOWEVER, gets a bit too involved, mouthes off at anyone who'll listen and also isn't scared to get stuck in with both his feet if he doesn't like someone.
Would you take him back on loan next season? Definitely, I believe he'd become a hero here.
Is he good enough to play for the Arsenal first team next season, or will he be in the future? Maybe as a bit part, or a squad player, not for a long period of time though.

jpROOKERYwfc wrote:
he has bags of talent, was a slow starter IMO, has a very short fuse, has had a lot of arguments with linesman in particular. can score some stunning goals (sheff wed at home and yesterday at cov).
is certainly one for the future, not sure if its at arsenal though.

Evasive wrote:
Certainly an excellent player of the course of our season even though he took a little while to settle.
A very talented young footballer, but I doubt you will see him in your side next season. It is a large step up from Championship to Champions League.
Having said that, if you are not using him next season, send him back over the fence will you?

Whippendell Woods wrote:
Now my opinion is quite high.
After eight games, however, it was quite low but Henri has, in the words of these TV talent shows "been on quite a journey" this season.
Initially he was played as link behind a lone striker like Rooney often is - except we're Watford, not Man Utd.
He benefitted from being moved into playing alongside John Eustace but was still a little lightwieght and had a tendancy to disappear from games for extended periods.
And Henry didn't appear interested in getting stuck in and shirked all sorts of tackles. Also he was prone to shooting high, wide and handsome when a man of his talents and apparent ability could have placed shots or have a better volleying technique.
He suffered by comparison to Tom Cleverley who was Paul Scholes-like, not only in his immediate willingness to track back, tackle and run off the ball but who possessed a better shooting and free kick ability. Henry looked a bit fancy dan by comparison.
He should have had many more goals than he did get, and seemed to have a lax attitude in taking chances that came his way which came back to bite us when teams punished us for wasting so many chances so casually in the first half of matches.
The Sky Sheffield Wednesday game was an exception than the rule but thankfully did appear to give Henry confidence.
But towards Xmas the penny dropped and suddenly he started to roar into tackles like a lion provoked. Rash at times, as alluded to by somebody above but it was apparent that he cared. For instance he could have missed three key games at the end of the season for a two footed lunge in a home game but the ref took pity.
At places like Barnsley away, he dominated and commanded, easily outclassing the bullying sort of midfielders and defenders you get in the Championship.
He was the player trying to whip up his younger colleagues when things weren't going well and you could see him trying his damndest, even if the consequences of potential relegation weren't going to affect him next season. That was wonderful to see. He has leadership potential.
Arsenal-wise he reminds me more of the younger Brian Talbot (without the shot) if you're old enough to know what I mean?
He is young and I feel he needs a speciality, such as a long throw or corners, a more consistent free kick technique and an improved passing completion record to be of use to Arsenal but , in future, being around better players than we've got at Watford, who knows?
Too good for us but as some have said, not ready for your first team squad perhaps.
Liked him and enjoyed the player he became, if not the one that first arrived. If he carries on improving at this rate, he'll be an international.....

sod chip save luther wrote:
On Henri, he needs to work out what he wants to be as a midfielder, as I think the days of the box to box midfielder are up-he's either got to be an attacking midfielder or a defensive midfielder. it's the same problem Jack Cork's got. Clearly a good footballer, but has to work out what he wants to be.

Jay Emmanuel-Thomas
Blackpool (Coca-Cola Championship)
Apps: 6+5 Goals: 1
Loan started: August 15
Loan end: November 7

fyldeflyer wrote:
1. Took a while for him to get going at first, a good few fans started to get on his back being Arsenal and all that, possibly expecting too much.
2. Usually central midfield.
3. Strengths he's a big physical lad.
Weaknesses if the ball did not go within about 3 yards of him he gave up.
4. Depends what division we are in, prem no championship possibly.
5. At the moment i would say no, needs to prove he can do it in the championship first.

Jay Emmanuel-Thomas
Doncaster (Coca-Cola Championship)
Apps: 12флуд Goals: 5
Loan started: February 27
Loan end: End of season

DonnyNoel wrote:
How has Jay played for you this season?
Very well. Started on fire, had a tiny lull in the middle but finished ver strongly. Always wants the ball and can change a game in an instant.
What sort of role/position has he played?
Very much a free role/attacking midfielder role behind a lone striker in either a 4411 or 4321.
What are the strengths and weaknesses in his game?
Strengths - passing, dribbling, shooting, hold up play, long throw. Weaknesses - heading, running the channels.
Would you take him back on loan next season?
Absolutely. Would love him here for pre-season although that hasn't always been Wengers policy in the past.
Is he good enough to play for the Arsenal first team next season, or will he be in the future?
Hard to say. His role with us, in Arsenal terms, is like Kanu and we gear the team up to allow him to play like that. In your current system with wide attackers like Nasri/Rosicky/Walcott behind one striker he perhaps isn't "energetic" enough for that but then thats the way we play him. He's certainly worth keeping an eye on should you want a player who can get a bit closer to Bendtner/RVP in a 4411 then he might be able to do that.

JamieM wrote:
How has Jay played for you this season?
Overall, very good.
What sort of role/position has he played?
Attacking midfielder/striker, sometimes played on the wing. Generally a link man between midfield and the front line
What are the strengths and weaknesses in his game?
Strengths - Excellent ball control, good skill, has a mean shot on him, a ''match winner''. Can create things out of nothing.
Weaknesses - Sometimes lazy, needs to work on his ''off the ball'' game. Quite slow, has been performing inconsistently for us (more consistent towards the end of his loan spell though)
Would you take him back on loan next season?
Definitely yes.
Is he good enough to play for the Arsenal first team next season, or will he be in the future?
He will be in a few years however needs to work on his off the ball game. Send him here for a full season and he'll be ready

CusworthRovers wrote:
If you speak Yorkshire then fine.....however I have been kind enough to also write an English version.
How has Jay played for you this season?
English. Very well.
Yorkshire. Different t'gravy.
What sort of role/position has he played?
English. He's played behind the striker, but he's also played out wide and could not get in the game. The free role, ie anywhere in the middle and up front is ideal in our system and for him.
Yorkshire. Proper bo wherever he gus. E fits in weeerever
What are the strengths and weaknesses in his game?
English. Strengths are...he has one of the hardest truest shots I have seen, (but note the type of players I am used to watching). When he's on his game and in the game, he's un-playable at our level. Weakness. Needs to nurture his footy brain and still learning, and needs a shout......'ie give me the fcuking ball'.
Yorkshire. He's rate gud, but needs some t'umph in his game.
Would you take him back on loan next season?
English. Yes and sign him, if we had the money.
Yorkshire. He needs t'stay away from t'fast cars, and neetlife.
Is he good enough to play for the Arsenal first team next season, or will he be in the future?
English. No and not under Arsène. I do not feel he is the type of player to lead the line ala Bendtner, RVP. Not that these dominate defences anyway physically. He would have to improve physically and his knowledge of the role ie how to make himself available and an outlet. I'm not sure he'll get that at a club like yours, considering the players you are linked with and have. That leaves him with his best position IMO ie the free role or the link player. Looking at your players they are all about speed, speed of play/thought and a very high work rate. JET would struggle here, I'm afraid at this moment in time and I fear in the future. I feel Arsène would have to change his tactics/team to accommodate him, and I'm not sure he will do that, when he has millions at his disposal to resolve any tactical issue.
Yorkshire. Once he's had a couple of sesh's down t'ale house and necked some tetley's down him, he'll be fit for owt.

BobG wrote:
The thing that stood out about JET for me was just how unblievably difficult it often was for opposing players to get the ball off him when he had it under control. His strength is enormous. I saw three Derby County defenders in succession simply bounce off him. He does have the ability to create something from nothing. His shooting is good too. He can be a match winner therefore. But he is also lazy. Whilst that got better as his stay here progressed, I can't see him being more than bit part player for the Arsenal until he decides to get much, much more involved on a very regular basis. His long throw is handy too

Kyle Bartley
Sheffield United (Coca-Cola Championship)
Apps: 9+4 Goals: 0
Loan started: February 9
Loan end: End of season

Odders wrote:
1. He's been average. His best performances were the last 3 games.
2. He's played CB
3. Strengths: Heading, Pace, good eye for a pass. Weaknesses: He needs some strength and he's Clumsy in the Tackle.
4. Yes I would take him back on a Season long loan, as long as it's got a clause that says he CAN'T be recalled.
5. NO, not next season. He's very raw but has the attributes to become very good. Morgan is a great teacher to have, If Wenger had any sense he'd send him to us to learn off Morgs. Morgan's partners have mainly gone on to become great players (Jagielka, Cahill, Kilgallon, to name a few)

BigMick1889 wrote:
I would agree with pretty much all of that. I don't think it's a surpris that he started to play exceptionally well when our play off chance had gone and we actually started playing some decent football. When we were playing the ball around nicely he looked much more composed and comfortable. Would definitely have him back next season and he has a very bright future ahead of him

Katchouro wrote:
We should also point out that Bartley has made a few cameos as a centre forward ... and hasn't looked out of his depth in that position.
I'd pretty much agree with Odder's assessment. He's one for Arsenal's future and is committed to getting as much experience as he can (in interviews he said Chris Morgan had taken him under his wing) in 1st team competitive football.

manorblade wrote:
I think Bartley has a great future but he's way off Arsenal first team, the kid started well but then started getting bullied from big no questions asked champ strikers, his form dropped for a while but you could see that Morgan beside him gave him more confidence to take on the physical challenge.
I thought he got better towards the end of the season and would happily see him back on loan, His confidence grew and helped him handle certain situations better than the first part of his loan.
I think if we would have had another 10 games left he would have got better and better.

blades58 wrote:
The word I would look for to describe him at the moment is inconsistant. Good performance followed by a dodgy performance. However, this is no more than I would expect from an 18 year old.
To add to that, I believe he will only improve, his consistancy will also improve and he has plenty of scope to do so imo.
I hope he comes back next season.

Telfordblade wrote:
Kyle played ok for us - he actually got better and better as the season went on - I guess it took him time to settle.
Would I have him back next year? Yes definitely
Is he 1st team material for Arsenal? not yet no
Will he be? Probably yes because one of his best assets is pace and ability to read the game - both essential at the top level.
Weaknesses? for me strength is his bioggest weakness (although that improved in the time he was with us) and for me he didnt win enough headers initially for such a big lad (again improved as time went on)
Roles played - mainly centre half but 2 cameos as a forward.
Overall Id say he did well for us and as I said, improved as time went on. He seemed to settle and improved game by game towards the end of the season. He needs a big strong centre half alongside him at our level to help him cope with the more 'physical' aspects, but certainly has the assets to be a top defender in terms of ability, composure, reading the game and pace. Good luck to the lad and I hope we get him back for the season.

[Ray]

Молодец Ирка, и молодец этот Рикки!
Но самый клёвый там репорт был про Джека. Добавлю:

Скрытый текст

Jack Wilshere
Bolton Wanderers (Premier League)
Apps: 12флуд Goals: 1
Loan started: January 29
Loan end: End of season

hisroyalgingerness wrote:
He took a little bit of time to settle in and for his team mates to get used to him but once settled I think he emerged as our best player in the last 2 months of the season.

We've seen him employed on the left wing and as one of the centres in a 4-4-2.

His ball control and running with the ball is exceptional, and unfortunately his team mates around him don't really have the footballing brain to match his vision. Defensively was found wanting occasionally but for an Arsenal player he was a good little terrier who wasn't frightened of sticking his boot in - including some spicy tackles in the Tottenham game you may or may not be pleased to note. (I've an image of Wenger with a headmaster's cap wagging a finger going "have you been making some tackles Jack, naughty, naughty).

Def take him back. I think he would play plenty of games, and hopefully we'll have some better players around him to take advantage.

Maybe not good enough for next season (honest guv) but he could eventually replace Cesc when he foxtrot oscars to Barca.

andyb99 wrote:
i really rate him and wish we could keep him permanantly...but i reckon he's a bit good for us right now.
as said his ball control and vision is exceptional....he's very cool on the ball. in truth though...cesc and ramsey (when he's fit again) are better at the moment...so maybe he won't get in the side....but he's got time on his side. a future internation star i'm sure

MJH-12 wrote:
How has Jack played for you this season?
As HRG said, he took a bit of time to settle but the goal against West Ham was the turning point. He's been a fantastic asset over the past 2/3 months and one of the first names on the teamsheet in my opinion
What sort of role has he played? Left wing, cutting in constantly.
What are his strengths and weaknesses? Very strong, very direct and a fantastic dribbler of the ball. Can be a bit naive when tackling and his final ball isn't always best but the lad is 18, I've got nothing but great things to say about him!
Would you take him back on loan next season? In a heartbeat. I'd even suggest Coyle tests Wenger's resolve in keeping hold of him permanently
Is he good enough to play for the Arsenal first team next season, or will he be in the future?
Not next season, but he's an England midfielder in the future without question. He is only going to get better.

H. Pedersen wrote:
How has Jack played for you this season?
He's been a great acquisition. He scored a critical goal against West Ham and set up one against Pompey. Very few players on our team have the ability to run with the ball like him.

What sort of role has he played?
He's played left midfield, central midfield, and behind a lone striker.

What are his strengths and weaknesses?
Strengths are a willingness to run with the ball and a tenacious attitude. I'm sure you'll get some people in this thread who think that any modicum of ability is associated with laziness and petulance, but he does play defense and works had to recover the ball.

Weaknesses, he does foul too much. Having played at Arsenal he's probably not yet adjusted to teams that don't have the referees on their side. He also dithers on the ball which caused us to concede a goal against Portsmouth. Probably looking for options and movement that just aren't there.

Would you take him back on loan next season?
In a second.

Is he good enough to play for the Arsenal first team next season, or will he be in the future?
In the future, yeah probably. Next season, depends. If you keep Fabregas I don't see a major role for Wilshere yet.

FaninOz wrote:
Excellent player who would grace any Premiership team, most now and the likes of Arsenal, Chelsea and United in a year or two.

Played well out wide or in central midfield, excellent ball control, vision , passing and is agressive when he needs to be. Got any eye of goal as well.

Don't let him go, unless you sell him to us of course, as he will be a major star in a year or two. After another season learning his trade back at Bolton that is, so don't let him go on loan to anyone else.

Sir Nut wrote:
How has Jack played for you this season?
Firstly Coyle played him out of position for most games playing him wide left, he isnt a winger, as soon as he put him in the middle he was exceptional

What sort of role has he played?
Lm then CAM where he would be clearly more effective playing around more intelligent players.

What are his strengths and weaknesses?
Strenghts are - can use both feet, can turn both ways, has an excellent touch, excellent Vision, puts a foot in, suprisingly strong. Weaknesses, he's playing around players like Davies and Taylor so you cant really point out his weakneses out, if i was narrow minded i would say he hogs the ball to much, but the reason for that is the players around him dont move into the space and give him 0% option (which you can see he doesnt like) of course that would change at arsenal.

Would you take him back on loan next season?
Me personally no, i dont like the fact we are training somebody up in one of the most unique positions and is a unique type of player, its like hanging a carrot in front of our face but never being able to reach it. We already have a player who i rate more that Wilshire (my opinion) Mark Davies if he stays free of injury so id like to see M Davies take the centre role next season.

Is he good enough to play for the Arsenal first team next season, or will he be in the future?
Deffinately for both questions, he would fit perfectly in the middle, with Van Persie, Arshavin, Nasri, Walcott (who i dont rate that much) all running of him, he has the vision like i stated and always moves in the space to recieve the ball, if it means dropping deep like Paul Scholes does or making a forward run for the intricate passing he'll be there, he has Arsenal all over him and would fit in like a cog in clock for Wengers style.

David Lee's Hair wrote:
How has Jack played for you this season?
Very well indeed. Started slowly when played out wide (I think it's harsh to say he was bad there), but in the West Ham game in particular he did very well as he adjusted to playing out of his natural position. When he moved into the centre I think we saw more of the real Wilshere. Shows the odd glimpse of immaturity in some decisions, but on the whole he's been very good. I'd say second half of the season he's been one of our best players, along with Knight and Muamba.

What sort of role has he played?
Played out left early doors, and did ok. The last few games played centrally, and you'll be happy to hear this, was the best player on the park against Spurs...

What are his strengths and weaknesses?
He's got good vision, a couple of times for us he's passed into a great space but no one has gone there. I guess a Fabregas or Van Persie would have moved there. For a little guy he's strong and not afraid to get stuck in. Decent pace, and low centre of gravity give him pretty good balance. The most impressive thing for me has been the runs he makes, against Spurs he was the best player on the pitch, and he kept making great darting little runs at angles onto the ball which meant that he was either past his man or they had to bring him down. He made Palacios and Huddlestone look distinctly average (bar Huddlestones shooting that is!)

It’s hard to say what his weaknesses are at the moment. He's a young lad and some of his decisions have been poor, but that comes with experience

Would you take him back on loan next season?
Yes, most certainly, and it'd benefit Arsenal no end too, jumping the gun on the last question I don't think he'll be starting for you next year.

Is he good enough to play for the Arsenal first team next season, or will he be in the future?
Not yet. He's basically up against Fabregas, Arshavin and Nasri, and he's not as good as any of them at the moment - I doubt he'll ever be as good as Fabregas (not many are) but he's got the potential to be as good as if not better than the other two, so I guess it all depends if he'll be happy with cameo appearances, or if Wenger decides to let him have a full season in a first team.

Dujon wrote:
Ricky 1985
Ignore all the above posts, please; young Jack is not fit to wear your shirt. Truly and honestly and fair dinkum he isn't. Mr Wenger should get rid of him as soon as possible.
Can we buy his contract? Pretty please with sugar and spice and all that stuff? Go on - you know you want to.
:-р

Prufrock wrote:
Sir Nut. 'can use both feet'? He can use his right as well as most of us can, for standing on. And Mark Davies better? I mean it's all opinions, so fair enough, but I disagree hugely. To cut to the chase for the questions, he's been cracking for us, another season on loan here and he'll slot nicely wide right of your 4-5-1.

irie Cee Bee wrote:
The boy is brilliant !

Lets make the most of it while we have him. We haven't had a midfield talent like him at Bolton since Jay Jay Ococha...

Почитав всё это, теперь думаю что аренды Уилширу будут только во вред - пора ему уже в нашу основу вливаться.

Сообщение отредактировал Ray: 15 May 2010 - 10:53

[caymN]

Насчет Уилшера не согласен. Парень больше опыта получит находясь в аренде, зато в основе, чем у нас, но хорошо если на скамейке. Еще годик в аренду а потом уже и к нам можно.